Child Custody – Welfare of the Minor – Visitation Rights Modified – Daily visitation ordered by the Family Court was deemed excessive, disrupting the child's routine – Held: Visitation schedule modified to twice weekly (Tuesdays and Sundays), ensuring the child's welfare while preserving the father-daughter bond [Paras 41-56].
Parental Alienation &ndash...
Family Law – Summoning of Witness – Application under Order XVI Rule 1(3) of CPC – Quashing of Family Court Order – Lack of Reasoning in Dismissal – Petitioner filed an application to summon a mediator as a witness in ongoing matrimonial dispute proceedings, asserting the relevance based on prior references to the individual’s mediation role in testimony –...
Grounds for Divorce – Desertion – Long-Term Separation Constituting Desertion - The appellant argued that the trial court erred in granting a divorce on grounds of desertion without specifically establishing intent (animus deserendi) as required under Section 13(1)(ib) of the H.M. Act – Held: The Court confirmed that the prolonged separation of over 27 years without reasonable ca...
Matrimonial Law - Interim Maintenance – Quantum and Standard of Living – Maintenance Restored – The wife sought interim maintenance of ₹2,50,000 per month, initially awarded ₹1,75,000 by the Family Court but reduced to ₹80,000 by the High Court – Supreme Court restored the Family Court's award, emphasizing the husband's substantial income and the wife's en...
Title and Possession – Suit for Partition – Inheritance under Modified Mitakshara Law – Appeal from High Court decision granting partition – Supreme Court reverses decision, upholding First Appellate Court’s findings. Clarifies legal heirs’ entitlement and lease agreements related to property. Affirms that Chiruthey lost her rights in her first husband’s p...
Family Law – Interim Maintenance – Execution of Maintenance Orders – Appeal Dismissed – The appellant challenged the execution of an interim maintenance order passed under Section 36 of the Special Marriage Act, contending that the order was not enforceable under Section 39A, which applies to orders passed under Chapters V or VI, while Section 36 is in Chapter VII – H...
Criminal Law – Sections 498A and 306 IPC – Discharge Application – Partial Discharge Granted – Appellants accused of subjecting the deceased (wife of appellant no. 1) to physical and mental harassment, including selling her streedhan and torturing her when she demanded its return – Alleged harassment led to the deceased committing suicide by hanging – Sessions C...
Matrimonial Law - Maintenance Pendente Lite – Section 24 HMA – Independence from Divorce Petition – Appellant argued that withdrawal of the divorce petition rendered Family Court functus officio to decide maintenance – Held: Section 24 proceedings are independent and survive withdrawal of the main case – Statutory provisions aim to ensure financial security of the dep...
Matrimonial Law – Divorce - Cruelty – Mental Illness and Suppression of Facts – Divorce Granted – The appellant-husband sought divorce on the grounds of mental cruelty caused by the respondent-wife’s erratic and unsound behavior, which was allegedly suppressed at the time of marriage – Evidence presented by the appellant, including his testimony and that of his ...
Criminal Law – Quashing of FIR – Allegations under Section 498A IPC and Sections 3 and 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act – FIR and chargesheet challenged as vague, retaliatory, and without specific evidence – FIR quashed.
Matrimonial Dispute – Allegations of Dowry Harassment – FIR No.82 of 2022 dated 01.02.2022 was registered against the appellants und...